Progressive Overload

Load or reps, and how your next set is chosen.

More weight or more reps?

Progressive overload is the one rule nobody argues with: to keep growing, training has to keep getting harder. The argument is about how. Do you add weight to the bar, or reps at the same weight?

What the research shows

It has been tested head to head. In an eight-week trial, forty-three trained lifters started in the same rep range. One group added weight whenever they could and kept their reps where they were. The other kept the weight where it was and added reps. Leg muscle growth was similar, with one thigh muscle growing slightly more in the reps group. Strength gains slightly favoured the weight group, by a margin the authors doubted was meaningful.

A second trial ran the comparison inside the same people. New lifters trained one leg by adding weight and the other by adding reps for ten weeks. Both legs gained the same size and the same strength.

Gains in ten weeks, one leg on each method
Thigh muscle size
  • Added weight+10%
  • Added reps+11%
Leg extension strength
  • Added weight+31%
  • Added reps+29%

Chaves et al. (2024), worked out from the reported group averages

So the muscle does not much care which number goes up. What it responds to is sets that stay hard as you get stronger, and either route does that.

Progress is a result, not a setting

The part that is easy to get backwards: adding weight does not cause the growth. You can add weight because you grew stronger. A plan that adds load on a schedule, whether or not the reps were there, soon turns hard sets into grinding ones and full reps into short ones.

What Stimuli does with it

The progression rules described here arrive in the next Stimuli update. A suggestion for every set is in the app today.
A suggestion for every setOn the Workout screen each exercise shows a suggested weight, reps and RIR for your next set, worked out from what you did last time. Tap it to log the set as suggested.
An exercise on the Workout screen showing the suggested weight, reps and RIR for the next set above the set already logged
Reps lead, load followsA program gives each exercise one rep target. Beat it with reps to spare at the planned effort and the next suggestion goes up in weight and returns you to the target. Match it and you repeat. That is both methods from the trials in one: reps first, then load.
Effort is part of the evidenceThe same weight and reps at a higher RIR is progress. At a lower RIR it is not, and a set that cost more than last time never earns a heavier one.
Do not expect every session to beat the last. Progress in trained lifters comes in steps, and a lift that repeats its numbers for a few sessions is normal. A lift that slides for weeks is a different matter: see the “Deloads” guide.

Sources

  1. Plotkin D et al. (2022). Progressive overload without progressing load? The effects of load or repetition progression on muscular adaptations. PeerJ.
  2. Chaves TS et al. (2024). Effects of resistance training overload progression protocols on strength and muscle mass. International Journal of Sports Medicine.

Keep reading

Train with science

Stimuli gives every muscle an Effective Work score as you log sets, and shows you where it landed.

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play