Machines and Free Weights

What the equipment changes, and what it cannot.

Does the equipment matter?

Free weights build “real” muscle, machines are for beginners and bodyweight is for conditioning. All three ideas are older than the evidence, and none of them holds up well against it.

What the research shows

A 2023 meta-analysis pooled the trials comparing free weights with machines. Muscle growth did not differ, though only a handful of the trials measured it. Strength did differ, in a predictable way: people who trained with free weights improved more on free-weight tests, and machine training tended to do the same for machine tests.

A controlled trial the same year gave thirty-eight trained men eight weeks of matched programs, one group on free weights and one on machines. Muscle size and strength improved equally. An earlier trial in men and women found the same for muscle size, and showed the specificity plainly: on the machine bench press, the group that trained on machines gained more.

Machine bench press strength gained in eight weeks
  • Trained on machines+13.9%
  • Trained with free weights+8.6%

Schwanbeck et al. (2020)

Bodyweight holds up too, within limits. When push-ups were set up to match a light bench press and both were taken to failure, eight weeks produced similar chest and triceps growth. That was a small study against a light load, so it shows that a hard push-up is real training, not that it replaces heavy pressing.

What the equipment does change

A muscle responds to tension and effort. It cannot tell what is supplying them. What the equipment changes is everything around that.

StabilityOn a machine the path is guided, so the set usually ends when the target muscle does. On a lunge or a single-leg lift, balance can end it first. Stable exercises make it easier to take the muscle itself close to its limit.
Where the lift is hardestA cable, a dumbbell and a machine can make the same movement hardest in different parts of the range. See “The Stretched Position”.
SkillStrength is specific to what you practise. If you want a bigger barbell squat, you have to squat with a barbell.

What Stimuli does with it

It builds from what you haveTell Stimuli whether you train in a full gym, a home gym, with dumbbells only or with bodyweight, and it builds your program from that equipment.
Bodyweight counts as loadOn pull-ups, dips and push-ups, your own bodyweight is the load and anything you add stacks on top. Those sets earn Effective Work like any other.
A profile for each machineStack numbers are not comparable between machines. If you do the same exercise on two different machines, give each its own Machine profile from the exercise’s options menu on the Workout screen. Each profile keeps its own history, records and suggestions.
The options menu of a leg press on the Workout screen, listing Reorder, Replace, Add note, Machine profile, Rest time, How to log and Remove
Pick the version of an exercise you can load, repeat and push hard without anything hurting. That matters more than what it is made of.

Sources

  1. Haugen ME et al. (2023). Effect of free-weight vs. machine-based strength training on maximal strength, hypertrophy and jump performance: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Sports Science, Medicine and Rehabilitation.
  2. Hernández-Belmonte A et al. (2023). Free-weight and machine-based training are equally effective on strength and hypertrophy: challenging a traditional myth. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise.
  3. Schwanbeck SR et al. (2020). Effects of training with free weights versus machines on muscle mass, strength, free testosterone, and free cortisol levels. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research.
  4. Kikuchi N, Nakazato K (2017). Low-load bench press and push-up induce similar muscle hypertrophy and strength gain. Journal of Exercise Science and Fitness.

Keep reading

Train with science

Stimuli gives every muscle an Effective Work score as you log sets, and shows you where it landed.

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play